A good engineer always does some reality checks. So, if you forgot about rotational inertia, you’d quickly see from the calculated vs. measured acceleration of any car that it gathers momentum more slowly than the power and the weight would suggest it should. Everything that rotates must be accelerated both in the direction that you’re trying to go, but also in rotation. For most of the car this is pretty much a constant (wheels, brake disks, driveshafts, differential etc.). The rotating mass really does act like having a heavier car because, if you roll off the gas and allow the car to coast down, it also behaves like a heavier car. Rotational inertia works like linear inertia.
Now, engine rotation (and part of the gearbox) is a bit different here. The effect of engine rotation changes when you change gear. In 1st gear the engine has to accelerate to high RPM over a small speed range so its rotational inertia has a greater impact than in top gear. This rotational inertia can be used to your advantage when changing gear (e.g. 2nd to 3rd) if your gear change is fast and the car can handle the “impact” of suddenly slowing the engine rpm down to that which matches car speed in the higher gear. Be careful with reliability! When you are wheelspin limited, the power can help you overcome drivetrain inertia, but undriven wheels still slow acceleration.
Back in 1985, I was trying to introduce lap time simulation to the F1 team for which I was working. When I asked the engineers what the inertia values were for various parts of the car, they had that blank look that tells you someone hasn’t really understood what you’re talking about. Unfortunately, even when I explained what I wanted the information for, it quickly became clear that this sort of engineering information wasn’t available. I had to reverse engineer the information for myself (we didn’t use computer aided design then).
For reasons such as saving costs and limiting the use of exotic materials (which are unlikely to find their way into road cars), the rules force F1 engine builders to make relatively heavy engines (compared to what is possible). Don’t get me wrong – they are light compared to road car engines generally speaking. In fact just fitting a functioning rev limiter to protect the engine from over revving was a challenge on certain F1 engines in the past (we had less knowledge but more freedom then). Simple (crude) rev limiting devices cut the spark to an increasing number of cylinders over as narrow a rev range as is practical until the RPM levels fall below a critical level. With the lightest of engines one piston firing at higher rpm when the engine was unloaded was enough to send the engine significantly into the red. Thus, engineers invented tools to limit the rate of acceleration of the engine. This engine protection was accepted by rule makers, and used in racing. Effectively ignition timing and spark cutting etc were used so that the engine behaved like a heavier unit, initially, for when it was disconnected from the weight of the car (e.g. in neutral).
All this because the engine’s moving parts were so light. Of course, give an engineer a tool and he’ll start thinking about more useful things to do with it. As soon as it was possible to limit the rate of acceleration of the engine, some people started thinking about using it for traction control in 1st gear. All you needed to do was send the driver out to push the car - to tune what rate of acceleration you need. You have to use 1st because the acceleration of the car would be too slow in 1st, if you set the engine acceleration limit up in 2nd.
So naturally the drivers of the time (1990’s and I’m not going to say exactly when!), would complain like hell that they needed “it” more in 2nd or 3rd gear than in 1st. Enter the next part of having traction control when, in theory, you could not have it.
To explain I need to give some background. Back in the 1980’s, when working on a “Group C” Le Mans 24 hour car, we had a problem one year with a big misfire, late on in the race. We wasted some time changing the electronics / cables / spark plugs etc. Regrettably though the actual problem was that we’d burnt holes into some pistons. So why did this happen? Back then, we had a mechanical fuel injection system. Very simple in concept – you had a fixed volume of fuel that would be injected into the engine each power cycle (two revolutions) which changed with a cam that would modify that volume based on throttle position and some very small changes with RPM. Mapping in the more modern sense wasn’t really possible. During the race we had increasing atmospheric pressure (a high pressure region was coming in) combined with a crystal clear night (so the temperature dropped like a stone). Together these things conspired to increase air density and the engine, with its “fixed” fuel flow was running too lean.
![]() |
I would like to thank Martin Lee for this picture. See more from Martin here :- https://www.flickr.com/photos/kartingnord/5780987576/in/photostream/ |
Even with a mechanical system, to prevent this from happening you really just need to find a way to tweak the map based on measurements of temperature and pressure of the air going into the engine (air density). Ideally you’d want to measure humidity and fuel temperature as well. So engines were permitted to sense atmospheric pressure and hence you had all you needed to modify the limit rate of acceleration of the engine in any gear. But how? Well the atmospheric pressure sensor had to measure the pressure inside the airbox, because that is the air the engine is swallowing. The airbox is carefully designed by people like me to take full advantage of the forward velocity of the car to ram as much air in there as possible. This means we were increasing the air density. We weren’t allowed any sort of sensor that would tell the engine control unit (ECU) what gear the car was in. However, with some track testing, one could use the way pressure changed with speed in the airbox to determine that, if the pressure was "X" above the ambient level seen at the start of the race, then the car was likely to be in a certain gear. To refine that process you just needed to know the RPM (another purely engine parameter). Hey presto traction control.
![]() |
Streamlines in an engine "airbox" - lines show air pathways coloured by trumpet |
There are many ways of getting a feeling for the power of rotational inertia. Quickest way to have a look is perhaps to check out some videos that are out there already. For example :- www.youtube.com/watch?v=NeXIV-wMVUk or www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHQOctEvtTY
This is reblogged from Willem's LinkedIn account with his permission: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/what-did-i-do-formula-1-willem-toet?trk=mp-reader-card
For UK followers of the blog the following opportunities exist for anyone interested in Willem's work...
2 Dec 18:30 to 20:30 plus Oxford - Free public lecture - F1 Performance, Design and (maily) Aerodynamics see toet.eventbrite.co.uk There will be some entertaining stories and time for questions. Free, book early. This is the one to aim for if you work as it starts at 6:30 pm for 7 pm talk start point. Organised by the IMechE. Some refreshments available from 6:30 pm. Questions and discussion due to finish at 20:30 but I'm happy to discuss any questions you may have for a bit longer. I will bring additional material so we have the potential to illustrate answers to questions.
4 Dec - 13:00 - 17:00 approx. Southampton University (Building 45 room 0045 which should be on the ground floor and is a large lecture theater - see site map here https://www.southampton.ac.uk/assets/sharepoint/groupsite/Administration/SitePublisher-document-store/Documents/About/visit/highfield_accessible_routes.pdf). Guests welcome and free. First lecture is similar to the one on the 2nd - Formula 1 performance, design, & aerodynamics. This does not require specialist knowledge. Would be suitable for higher school pupils, motorsport enthusiasts, engineering students and engineers. After the first lecture we then focus more on the use of CFD to develop a race car (aimed at university students but anyone using CFD may find it interesting) and how new aerodynamic testing restrictions (in the FiA regulations) are changing the approach F1 teams are taking to aerodynamic development. There will also be discussions with the Formula Student team which are probably not open to all.
Amazing article. Very very interesting.
ReplyDeleteFantastic stuff.
ReplyDeleteAlthough watching the vido I believe he switched the directions of angular momentum and torque. Angular momentum is in the direction of rotation and torque follows the right hand rule. Later in the video when he hangs the weight on the wheel axle stud he verifies the rihht hand rule and thus the inadvertant directional switch at the beginning.
~Stigmacher
In these days with hybrid PU's why use "traction control" at all?
ReplyDeleteOne could simply detect these moments of "slip" and pulse battery charging as needed to make use of excess torque instead of using it to spin the tyres. This would allow for "traction control" within the rules, not cutting / changing engine control and put the wasted torque to use charging the battery through the MGUk system; drive shaft possibly?
Just some thoughts...
~Stigmacher
Wonderfull Explanation.. Thank You Very Much
ReplyDeletereadytorepair.in
APPLIANCE REPAIR
AC REPAIR AND SERVICE
GAS STOVE REPAIR
LAPTOP REPAIR
WASHING MACHINE REPAIR
Yes, I agree with you, and you had mention deep facts in this post and I’m enjoying reading.
ReplyDeleteEscort Girls Service | Delhi Escort Service | Chennai Call Girls | Pune Escort Service | Call Girls in Bangalore | Call Girls in Chandigarh
Wonderfull Explanation.. Thank You Very Much
ReplyDeleteAC REPAIR AND SERVICE
GAS STOVE REPAIR
LAPTOP REPAIR
WASHING MACHINE REPAIR
I feel happy about and learning more about this topic. keep sharing your knowledge regularly for my future reference. Thanks for sharing information like this. The information which you have provided is better than any blog. For more info you can visit us.
ReplyDeleteAC REPAIR AND SERVICE
GAS STOVE REPAIR
LAPTOP REPAIR
WASHING MACHINE REPAIR
I read your post, it was really a very good topic and the content that is in it is even better. I thank you very much for sharing this
ReplyDeletepost with us and I would like to read your post even further.
Escort Girls Service
Delhi Escort Service
Chennai Call Girls
Call Girls in Bangalore
Mumbai Escort Service
I Saw Your Website Carefully. Thanks For Create Such Kind of Informative Website. Your All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. I Say Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.
ReplyDeleteEscort Girls Service
Escort Service In Delhi
Mumbai Escorts Service
Call Girl In Chennai
Call Girl In Hyderabad
Call Girl In Bangalore
Best Deals at Paincarecircle, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world.
ReplyDeletePaincarecircle
buy oxycodone online
buy hydrocodone online
buy oxycontin online
buy percocet online
buy xanax online
buy adderall online
buy norco online
buy vicodin online
Found your post interesting to read. I cant wait to see your post soon. Good Luck for the upcoming update.This article is really very interesting and effective.
ReplyDeleteOur Services:
Digital marketing Company
SMM Services
PPC Ads Services
PPC Services in Delhi
Website Design & Development Packages
Seo Packages India
Best Deals at bestcartshop, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world.
ReplyDeletebestcartshop
buy oxycontin online
buy oxycodone online
buy percocet online
buy hydrocodone online
buy tramadol online
buy adderall online
buy xanax online
buy soma online
buy adipex online
Best Deals at royalkartshop, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world.
ReplyDeleteroyalkartshop
buy Oxycontin online
buy Oxycodone online
buy Xanax online
buy Hydrocodone online
buy Adderall online
buy Adipex online
buy Valium online
buy Tramadol online
buy Ambien online
Best Deals at easycareshop, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world.
ReplyDeleteeasycareshop
buy Oxycontin online
buy oxycodone online
buy Xanax online
buy Hydrocodone online
buy Adderall online
buy Vicodin online
buy Percocet online
buy Valium online
buy Tramadol online
royalkartshop
ReplyDeletebuy Oxycontin online
buy Oxycodone online
buy Xanax online
buy Hydrocodone online
buy Adderall online
buy Adipex online
ReplyDeletebuy Valium online
buy Tramadol online
buy Ambien online
buy Norco online
buy Soma online
buy Vicodin online
easycareshop
ReplyDeletebuy Oxycontin online
buy oxycodone online
buy Xanax online
buy Hydrocodone online
buy Adderall online
buy Vicodin online
ReplyDeletebuy Percocet online
buy Valium online
buy Tramadol online
buy Ambien online
buy Soma online
buy Adipex online
Best Deals at callmeds247, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world.
ReplyDeletecallmeds247
buy oxycodone online
buy hydrocodone online
buy adipex online
buy percocet online
buy adderall online
buy tramadol online
ReplyDeletebuy vicodin online
buy norco online
buy phentermine online
buy methadone online
Best Deals at bestcartshop, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world.
ReplyDeletebestcartshop
buy oxycontin online
buy oxycodone online
buy percocet online
buy hydrocodone online
buy tramadol online
buy adderall online
buy xanax online
buy soma online
Buy Adderall online at your door step from one & only trusted pharma in this ERA. Buying Adderall 30mg with Credit card.
ReplyDeleteOnline Front is one of the trustworthy and leading Digital Marketing Company In Delhi. We are one stop solution for all Digital Requirements.
ReplyDeleteVisit:-
free youtube subscribers
Digital Consultancy Services In Delhi
Website Development Packages
Website Designing Company In Delhi
Positive site, where did u come up the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include.
ReplyDeleteGastroenterologist
"I would like to say that, your blog is very nice, informative and amazing. Thanks for sharing your blog with us."
ReplyDeleteRefrigerator Repair Service in Delhi
Awesome post! Personally I like your site. . I am so impressed to read your content. I am looking forward for the next valuable and informative concept in your blog. Overall outstanding post. Carry on :) Well done!
ReplyDeleteIf Want Play Online Satta Game :-
Satta King
SattaKing
Satta King
Satta King
Best Deals at buyonlinekart, an international prescription service provider, which contracts with International dispensaries and USA pharmacies, is a leader in referring orders for prescription and non-prescription medications on behalf of customers throughout the world
ReplyDeletebuyonlinekart
Best place to buy hydrocodone online Hydrocodone is used to relieve severe pain. Again, hydrocodone is only used to treat people who are expected to need medication to relieve severe pain around-the-clock for a long time and who cannot be treated with other medications or treatments. Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy hydrocodone online
Buy Oxycodone Online Oxycodone is a semisynthetic narcotic integrated from thebaine, a narcotic alkaloid found in the Persian poppy, and one of the numerous alkaloids found in the opium poppy. It is a respectably intense narcotic agony drug (orally generally 1.5 occasions more strong than morphine), for the most part demonstrated for alleviation of moderate to extreme torment . Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy oxycodone online
Buy Oxycontin Online. OxyContin (oxycodone HCl) is indicated for the management of pain severe enough to require daily, around-the-clock, long-term opioid treatment and for which alternative treatment options are inadequate. Limitations of Use. Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy oxycontin online
Buy Percocet Online which is used to help relieve moderate to severe pain. It contains a opioid (narcotic) pain reliever (oxycodone) and a non-opioid pain reliever (acetaminophen). Oxycodone works in the brain to change how your body feels and responds to pain. Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy percocet online
In the event that you are hoping to buy Vicodin online or you want Vicodin for sale, Our online drug store is the ideal asset for individuals to get their medications without remedy or any issues or ponderousness. We endeavor to profit each time you shop with us. For the reason that At our online store, you save money and get more. Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy vicodin online
Buy Norco online Buy Norco online-without prescription,without any hassle with securepharma . We have best panel of doctors registered with us,who is taking care of all formalities like valid doctor’s prescription and all.To buy Norco online please make an order on our website or you can also call our executive. Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy norco online
Buy Adderall online for Adults and children now without prescription, only at heyleel.com It is a time-released drug so that its effects and benefits are given throughout the day and people who need it can perform well without symptoms from their condition. Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy adderall online
Buy Xanax online Alprazolam , sold as the trade name Xanax among others, is a short-acting benzodiazepine. It is most commonly used in short term management of anxiety disorders, specifically panic disorder or generalized anxiety disorder . Call Now 1-805-335-6339.
ReplyDeletebuy xanax online
Really nice blog, thank you so much for this informative blog sharing with us. Buy designer laddu gopal dress from Mathura Vrindavan.
ReplyDeleteI have been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or blog posts in this kind of area . Exploring in Yahoo I ultimately stumbled upon this web site. Reading this information So i am glad to show that I have an incredibly good uncanny feeling I came upon exactly what I needed. I such a lot indubitably will make certain to don't forget this web site and give it a look a relentless basis.
ReplyDeleteIf Want Play online Satta King Games Click Satta King:-
Buy Hydrocodone Online with Paypal, Order hydrocodone overnight delivery 10/325 MG 100 PILLS. Buy hydrocodone online for pain relief with a credit card.
ReplyDeleteOrder Now -
Buy Hydrocodone Online
Buy Generic Viagra Online
easycareshop
ReplyDeleteXanax is the newest development, serving clients online with their pharmaceutical needs. Our retail outlets are supported by an efficient Headquarter team based in United States.
Thanks for your marvelous posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author. I will remember to bookmark your blog and may come back in the foreseeable future.
ReplyDeleteRead More:-
Satta king
Buy Hydrocodone Online with Paypal, Order hydrocodone overnight delivery 10/325 MG 100 PILLS. Buy hydrocodone online for pain relief with a credit card.
ReplyDeleteOrder Now – Buy Generic Hydrocodone Online