Open top menu
11 Jun 2013

The Front Wing is an area of the car that undergoes significant development throughout the course of the season and has rapidly evolved during the current ruleset (Introduced in 2009)
The common perception when we talk about Wings and lift or negative lift (downforce) is a simple Wing profile:
Formula One teams have however over the last few years moved their Front Wing designs to feature 3 dimensional Deltoid shape Wings, these Wings are designed very differently and produce downforce and moreover Vortices in a different way.

These Deltoid shaped Wings rely to some extent on the generation of Vortices whereas a conventional Wing operates better without Vortices until it is pushed beyond it's intended Angle of Attack, only then will Vortices help to reduce the Boundary Layer build up by energising the airflow. (Boundary Layer is the layer of slow moving air above the surface that increases with distance or increased angle of attack. This is why we see teams apply Vortex Generators at the leading edge of the Sidepods, enabling them to work across a broader speed spectrum).

Deltoid shaped Wings are not an invention of F1 but another idea borrowed from the aerospace industry, you can see their application in famous airplanes such as Concorde, Lockhead Blackbird, Space Shuttle Orbiter amongst many, many others.


Another great example would be if I handed you a piece of paper and asked you to fold a paper airplane, rather than attempting to cut up the piece of paper and construct a wing with a leading edge and chord you would simply fold it into a deltoid.

The thin leading edge with a swept back design allows a deltoid Wing to operate under a much wider operating window than it's conventional wing counterpart (Low to High Speed). The swept design is critical in the generation of lift or negative lift as the separated airflow rolls up into a conical vortice at the outer edge that creates high energy and low pressure. As the speed increases so does the vortice generated, enabling much higher angles of attack to be achieved without the Wing stalling. (Something it's conventional Wing counterpart cannot achieve without assistance from leading edge Vortex Generators)


As the teams have explored the use of these deltoid shaped Wings the designs have become more complex with both Red Bull and Ferrari now sporting 7 tier arrangements. This is all to do with efficiency and is a trade off between maximum Angle of Attack and stability. The primary reason we see the flaps perforated at the outer edge is to increase their Vortex yield. In order to achieve the large level of AoA these Wings run without stalling, the perforation or slot is added in order to inject airflow from the high pressure side to the low pressure side. The same principle is applied with the Endplate with holes allowing airflow to move between the two sides and into the curved outer element of the mainplane / flaps.  This curvature creates the space for which the Vortex rolls up and helps to create the downforce, this is also the principle reason we see drivers able to continue with broken Front Wings as a deltoid Front Wing doesn't require the Endplate to increase it's aspect ratio.  The Front Wing could be seen as two parts with the inbound end creating downforce and more straightforward Vortices from the flap tips, whilst the outboard sections function is primarily to create vortices that aid in controlling the airflow that migrates around the Front Wheels.




Red Bull introduced an interesting development to the RB9's Front Wing in Montreal applying Vertical Strakes on both the Mainplane and Secondary Flap. These are of particular interest as I have not seen the devices used on the Front Wing in F1 before (Although I'm sure someone will now correct me).

These guide Strakes have been added to the RB9's Front Wing in order to assist in the delta wings ability to generate Vortices over a wider range than if they weren't in use. Assisting the Strakes that feature under the Wing they help not only to guide the airflow for better extraction, circulation and vortex creation but aid when the car is in Yaw, allowing the airflow a staged finality to the Wing, effectively expanding and contracting the aspect ratio of the deltoid as the car moves around the corner.

This year teams have found their Wing designs need to be adjusted to further counteract the deformation of the Pirelli tyres. The organic compression and relaxation of the tyres Sidewalls cause the designers to rethink the way they approach the Vortices generated by the Front Wing. With their generation, direction and strength enabling differing airflow regimes further downstream (Toward the Splitter, Floors leading edge, Sidepods etc) its imperative the flow be adapted to challenge the wheels aerodynamic wake in order to re-use this airflow to extract extra performance.

Red Bull also re-evaluated the use of a Blown Wheel Nut system earlier in the season in another attempt to control the airflow around the wheel and manipulate the wake. It's an approach Williams have taken with the FW35 and although relatively unsuccessful it goes to show the importance of controlling the wheels wake.

Front Wing design will be an area of increased development by the teams throughout this season. Looking forward to 2014 the principle of turning air outbound of the Front Wheels will still likely feature, however due to the narrowing of the Front Wing by 150mm (75mm either side) a whole new learning curve will ensue.

I'd also like to thank @F1_Aero for his assistance in constructing elements of this article and as he pointed out to me:

Aerodynamics is a minefield! Fw's are insanely complex in the mechanisms involved in how they work.

So please understand I'm only trying to assist in the understanding of these highly complex devices that even the teams/designers are learning about on a daily basis
Tagged

6 comments:

  1. Great piece of article...

    Jael Arias

    ReplyDelete
  2. great article , thanks
    deltoids are also known to have high drag at relively low speeds. ie below transonic speeds.
    the winglets on modern aircraft are designed to stop the votox that is generated by more convential wings
    would that be why the red bulls have lower top speeds down the straights relative to other teams?
    because they produce more vorticies.
    or are they just using higher wing angles?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Matt, have you ever tried to apply a job in F1?
    I don't know if you have the specific formation, but you clearly could get a job inside...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Victor, I haven't and although I can't rule it out don't think it's really a possibility. My understanding is broad, whereas team personnel tend to work in very specific areas. Academically I'd also look very poor as I would consider myself to have life experience rather than qualifications that can back up my credentials. If I don't know something I research it and if the information isn't available I will reference from other area's forming an over arc-ing thesis. As I haven't studied I'd consider myself to have a patchwork of knowledge that I piece together in order to form an informed opinion/piece. (I soak up information like a sponge, must just be how my brain works)
      I'm not always right, but I learn from the mistakes I make and they lead to better, more informed pieces that hopefully are of benefit to everyone else.

      Delete
  4. Another great piece.
    But I don't really see how vortices can create downforce. All I know is that vortices should be avoided, at least when it comes to airplanes. As Anonymous allready pointed out, the winglets seen on modern aircraft are to suppress vortices, one to reduce drag and second to suppress vibrations.
    I can see the vortices break up the boundary layer, but the v-generators as shown on the redbull wing in front of the second segment can only lead to stalling the second segment (in my opinion).
    Or should it be seen as slowing down the airflow over the second wing, thereby increasing pressure on top of the wing?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Vortices don't create downforce per se, in this instance they are aiding in pulling the airflow under the Wing and moreover used as a way of manipulating the airflow around the wheel.
      The Strakes you refer to as Vortex Generators are simply guide vanes in this instance as VG's would be ineffective in that position on the Front Wing.

      Delete

Whilst I'm trying to keep atop of the blog you may have noticed of late that there is less content appearing. For those of you that haven't realised, most of my work has now been moved over to Motorsport.com where I'm working with Giorgio Piola.

I'm still doing the technical image gallery for each GP with the continued support of friend of the site Sutton Images. However, as always my time is limited and so this might not be updated as quickly as it once was, so keep checking back.

As some of you may have found out already I'm also working with the Missed Apex crew on their podcast from time-to-time, either doing race reviews or dedicated 'Tech Time' shows.

I've embedded the latest version of the podcast below and will update this a frequently as I appear. However, please head over to Itunes if you want it to appear in your player when episodes are available. The show is great to work on and has a great lineup of 'regulars' but has also enticed some bigger names recently too, with Will Buxton and Bradley Philpot on shows during the summer break.


Total Pageviews